Developer FiftyThree challenges Facebook over use of Paper for its app name

paper facebook

Facebook today launched its news reading app, Paper, but the launch was not without controversy. iOS development company FiftyThree was not pleased with the name of Facebook’s new app and petitioned the social network to change its name. FiftyThree is the company behind the drawing app Paper. Paper is well-known in the App Store and won Apple’s 2012 iPad App of the Year award. It launched long before Facebook’s app, so it’s reasonable for FiftyThree to be upset with Facebook’s choice of an app name.

So it came as a surprise when we learned on January 30th with everyone else that Facebook was announcing an app with the same name—Paper. Not only were we confused but so were our customers (twitter) and press (1,2,3,4). Was this the same Paper? Nope. Had FiftyThree been acquired? Definitely not. Then, what’s going on?

We reached out to Facebook about the confusion their app was creating, and they apologized for not contacting us sooner. But an earnest apology should come with a remedy.

There’s a simple fix here. We think Facebook can apply the same degree of thought they put into the app into building a brand name of their own. An app about stories shouldn’t start with someone else’s story. Facebook should stop using our brand name.

FiftyThree can ask Facebook to change its app name, but it likely doesn’t have the grounds to challenge it legally. As pointed out by TechCrunch, FiftyThree registered a trademark for its drawing app, but secured the word mark of “Paper By FiftyThree,” not “Paper.” There also are other apps that use the name Paper, including two that were launch before FiftyThree’s drawing app landed in the app store.

paper-trademark

In the end, the newspaper analogy implied in the name “Paper” maybe have been too much for Facebook to pass up, even if it means Facebook is treading very closely to the name of Paper by Fifty Three.

Like this post? Share it!

Categories: Facebook, iOS Apps

  • Alex

    The reason there are 2 apps named simply “Paper” is because the 1st app “Paper” by miSoft is a US app, the other “Paper” is registered in another country and made available for sale in the US; violating the spirit of the Review Guidelines (the two words do not have different meanings in different languages). The other “Paper” apps, including Paper the non-US clone, Paper by 53, and Paper by Facebook are scandalous. Apple, 53 and Facebook should be ashamed.

  • Alex

    BTW, just a little note for anyone interested in the truth, Apple has a rule against similar names, and the Release Date of 1.0 of an app is NOT the date it was created in iTunes connect, it can be months or years before while the app is both in development and/or going through attempts at approval.

    The notion of adding other words after the word “Paper” perhaps comes up after the word “Paper” is un-available!

    The question here is, why are others copying miSoft’s Paper?

  • Eric

    Paper by Fiftythree isn’t even in the App Store. I saw the other 2 apps though.

    • Candie

      yes it is
      Paper by 53 is def there

  • Candie

    miSoft entered the app store on Sept 20, 2012 with V1.0
    Paper by 53 was entered into the app store March 24, 2012 with V1.0

    Paper by 53 was launched in the app store almost a full six months before Paper by miSoft so the claim that Paper by 53 is also at fault doesn’t seem to hold up