Yesterday, the developer of PCalc received a message from Apple asking him to remove the calculator widget from his app within three weeks. The decision was quite surprising, not only because of how useful the widget was, but also because Apple had featured PCalc in the App Store under the Great Notification Center widgets section.
Following the backlash from the community, Apple today said that it has reversed its decision, and assured that PCalc’s Notification Center calculator widget will live on, and so will other calculator widgets on the App Store.
Now we’re hearing that Apple is changing its course. The PCalc app and widget will remain in the App Store, and all calculator-type widgets will be allowed as well, an Apple spokesperson has confirmed to us.
From our understanding, the calculator use case was not one that Apple had anticipated, which is why an App Store reviewer originally explained to Thomson that he would need to adjust the app, or risk being pulled from the App Store.
Apple has time and again been criticised for not making App Store guidelines clear enough, or not implementing them universally. Developers spend effort into building features, and the lack of clarity can poses a huge risk that could make all their efforts useless.
It still isn’t very clear what went behind Apple’s decision to remove the widget, and why it went back on its decision today.
Let us know what you think about this in the comments below.